It's the end of finals week and right before I started on this blog which was (well, is, I think) going to be about student emails, I worked up the courage/patience to check my voicemail. As we are in the middle of finals, and registration has finally, after a long, drawn-out extension, come to an end, my voicemail is usually full or urgent, panicky messages to the effect of, "I'm lazy and didn't get my crap together in time and now I need you to fix it!". Dealing with over a hundred finals, six classes, and two boxes full of papers that need grading is stressful enough already, so I generally tend to ignore any voicemail messages that involve serious bodily injury.
But anyway, I felt magnanimous just now, and dialed my voicemail service. And believe it or not, I do believe I got my first drunk message ever. Yes, people, ever. And it's from a student too. It's not offensive by any means, in fact, it's really no more than someone slurring my name while playing loud music and, by the sound of it, hosting a party in the background, but still. A drunk voicemail. And here I was thinking I would never be able to strike that one off my bucketlist, or share with my blog readers.
Anyway, student emails. For the past week or so, I have been inundated with emails regarding grades, extra credit, the fairness of grading (or lack thereof), the need to graduate, the need to take the final early, and other concerns that make the weeks around finals so particularly enjoyable.
Most emails fall into one of three categories: Good, bad, and ugly. Good emails are the easy emails. The ones that involve the need for an appointment (can do!), the link to the extra credit assignment (coming up!), or a genuine excuse for a missed class (why, thank you!). The bad emails are the ones that badger for extra assignments in an online class (if 9 quizzes, 9 discussion assignments, 9 graded assignments, 1 final, and 1 paper aren't enough to get that coveted C, I don't know what is), the ones that whine about a passing grade that is not within the sender's acceptable range (study harder! don't procrastinate! man up, a B is fine!), or the ones that try to get an extension without any sort of excuse (sorry, "I started late" just isn't acceptable). The ugly emails, are well, just that.
Some days consist of nothing but bad emails. Some days are worse, when you get one or two ugly ones, but yesterday was a perfect mixture of all three.
It started with an email from Unfair Ursula. Ursula had written a 20-page paper in a 14 sized font, which effectively reduced the paper to 16 pages, which made it below the required minimum. On top of that, Ursula's paper struggled with a whole host of issues, including but not limited to, a lack of sources, a lack of a clear central argument, and a lack of proper paragraphing. Because I did see some potential, and all wasn't lost completely, Unfair Ursula earned a C. Shortly after receiving her paper, Ursula then proceeded to send me the following email, which I would classify as bad:
"I looked over the comments you wrote on my paper, and I really don't feel I got the grade it should have. It seems as if the only reason I almost received a failing grade is because my font wasn't the correct size. The paper itself is actually good, I think. I'm also not happy that I almost failed the class when I know for a fact that you let another student turn their work in late, while you told everyone that if they turned their work in late, they would receive an F. Neither one of us followed the guidelines in the syllabus, and I almost failed while the student passed with an A? Not to say I deserve an A, but my paper was worth at least a B."
The email I wanted to send, but didn't:
"Dear Ursula,
I'm delighted that you feel your paper is worth a B. In fact, it seems as though you have managed to skip undergrad and graduate school completely, and are pretty much tenured faculty. Your acute ability to assign grades is truly unsurpassed, and you really are a shoe-in for chair, in fact. In addition, you're absolutely right that it's completely and utterly unfair that the rules are bent for other people. The fact that other people might have genuine excuses, real-life emergencies, or other sincere issues really doesn't matter. The fact is, he broke the rules, and so he should fail. And we'll just ignore the logical conclusion that you should then fail as well, won't we?"
Don't worry, you will all be delighted to know that I sent Ursula a professional, but brief email, outlining my reasoning behind her C, and wished her all the best.
Then there was the ugly. The ugly email came from Financial Frances. Frances had blatantly copied half a page of her final paper from Wikipedia. Yes, Wikipedia. Not only did she blatantly ignore my rule (clearly outlined in the syllabus) that students may not use Wikipedia, about.com, or answers.com in their papers, but she also failed to provide a source for the half page. Subsequently, Frances received a zero for the final paper, which, incidentally, was worth 30% of her final grade. As Frances' performance in class had not been swell at any rate, Frances knew she was going to fail the class. Thus she had begged me, in an earlier email, to allow her to redo her work. When I politely declined, I received the following email:
"If I am not allowed to resubmit my paper, can you please just take points off of my grade instead of giving me a zero. I cannot afford to fail this class as I will lose my scholarship and will not able to return to school. I beg you to reconsider your decision; my future depends on it"
And the email I actually did send back:
"Dear Frances,
Thank you for your email. I'm very sorry to hear about the possible consequences of your zero, however, I cannot change classroom, or for that matter, university, policy. The rules regarding plagiarism are very clear and it's up to each student to make sure they adhere to those rules, especially if they have this much riding on their final grade"
Seriously, people.
Fortunately, the day ended with a good email. Apologetic Annie had also plagiarized on her final paper, and tried to see me during the day, but left when she saw how busy I was. An hour later I received the following email:
"I came by your office today but you were drowning in papers because grades are due, so I decided to contact you by email. I am emailing you to discuss my final paper, for which I received a zero. I am fully aware that I received the zero because I plagiarized. I just wanted to make sure you knew I didn't do it on purpose, or out of laziness. I'm not trying to appeal my grade or anything like that.
I know that I am one of your good students and I hate that I disappointed you. I just wanted to contact you to inform you that I never wrote an APA paper and I misinterpreted how to cite sources. Another mistake that I made was not actually reading through the notes that you had posted on writing a research paper. It's all still my fault, and I fully accept the consequences."
I'm telling you, there's hope. There is.
3 comments:
Weer een mooi verhaal! Veel succes met de laatste loodjes..
Wow, I never begged a teacher for a better grade. Come to think of it, I did have my son ask for an early final exam once for a summer course, because this dumb mom booked an airline ticket a day too early. I was very grateful that the teacher let him!
I'm learning a thing or two from these blogs; I now am also dealing with students, and it is all fine when they do well, but when they don't it is very difficult! I had one tell me I was just looking for mistakes.
Good luck with the home stretch!
your posts boggle my mind with the way students act and what they expect. I'm sure it was like that when I went to college, but still. I mean, if you didn't do the assignment right or got it in late, you get penalized! That's not too hard to understand. I respect the last girl for owning up to her paper and not asking for a grade change.
Post a Comment