..really, people.
It's one thing to have students demand that classes be as fascinating as the latest Tyler Perry movie they saw, as intriguing as that Assassin's Creed game they're all addicted, and as interactive as Twitter, but when faculty start weighing in on this crazy snowflake-driven push towards college-is-like-kindergarten-have-a-balloon!, you know I'll have something to say about it.
My rant, this time, was caused by this article. Published on a website with the dubious name of "Faculty focus" (what's that? Like Focus on the Family for faculty?), the title "What does your syllabus say about you" is enough to make me cringe. Not only does the title sound like an article in Cosmo ("What does your wardrobe say about you!"), I struggle with the notion that my syllabus says anything other than what students need to do to pass.
Please, read the article. I beg you. I'll wait.
OK, I'm going to assume that about half of you just kept on reading, so let me, very quickly, summarize what the author had to say. Basically, she's asking all professors to critically review their own syllabi and ask themselves to following questions:
1. How would you characterize the tone of your syllabus?
2. Does your syllabus convey the excitement, intrigue, and wonder that's inherently a part of the content you teach?
3. Does your syllabus indicate that all the decisions about the course have been made? (Is there room for students to make some decisions regarding the course?)
4. Have you ever asked your students for feedback on your syllabus?
People, a syllabus is a multi-page document that explains the objectives, schedule, and rules associated with the class, complete with a contract at the end that students sign. It's not Maya Angelou's latest tome on spirituality, nor is it a missing episode from the Oprah show. It's a document used to facilitate the teaching of the course.
So what is the tone of my syllabus?
Well, business-like probably captures it well. I say things like, "Because tardiness is unacceptable in a professional environment, the instructor will deduct points from your participation grade for tardiness". Straightforward, to the point, no frills, bells, or whistles. According to the article, it's supposed to be "friendly and inviting", so I'm guessing that particular sentence is to be replaced with, "If you could come on time, that would be ever so wonderful?"
Does my syllabus convey excitement and wonder?
Uhm, what? Wonder? Isn't that something we associate with children around Christmas time?
Anyway, I'm going to be blunt here, no, probably not. Now do I convey excitement when talking to my class the first time? Yes. Does my syllabus "openly state the enthusiasm you feel about teaching this great subject"? No, but it's more of a, hey, you try to get away with x, y, or z, and this will happen feel. I'm guessing I need to sound a little more excited about the possibility of academic probation in the case of plagiarism, "Doesn't that sound like fun?!"
Does my syllabus indicate that all the decisions have been made?
Heck yes it does. Last time I checked, I was the one with the Ph.D., I was the one in front of the classroom, and all my students get to do is decide whether or not they want to buy the books or not. This is not a democracy. Isn't that what students pay me for? To tell them what they need to know? Or did I miss the memo that universities were now switching to a "user-based approach"?
And finally, have I ever asked the students for feedback?
I would, if the majority of them hadn't misplaced the syllabus by week two.
So yes, that would be a clear zero for Dr. D. A zero that I'm proud of, as I refuse to join in on the "I'm a rainbow unicorn and I love you all!" chorus that seems to be the general expectation among students now.
Don't get me wrong, I am all for interactive learning strategies, student engagement, and learning by doing. But I have enough experience to know that without clearly outlined rules, written down in a syllabus, and acknowledged in a contract, no one will be doing much learning at all.
So, what does my syllabus say about me?
Well, obviously, that I'm none other than Professor Coldheart himself.
2 comments:
Het is echt een tendens van de laatste jaren, dat onderwijs gelijk moet staan aan 'graag naar school komen', en dat dat Heilige Doel met alle middelen moet nagestreven worden. Ook als dat wil zeggen dat we onze kinderen leuke pretpakketjes moeten aanbieden ipv cognitieve kennis.
Had nooit durven vrezen dat dit zelfs tot in universitaire niveau's zou kunnen doordringen...
Dus wat mij betreft: lang leve jouw syllabus!
What's next? Moeten we de arbeidscontracten eens onder de loep gaan nemen? Zijn die wel uitnodigend en stimulerend genoeg?
The most exciting syllabus I ever had the privilege of receiving was printed on hot pink paper. It was exciting because it was printed on hot pink paper. The professor engaged the entire class, I don't think he worried about what his syllabus "said" to us. I think as long as you do your very best to engage the students, well then, the ball is in their court, so to speak.
Post a Comment