Just a precaution before I begin: if you don't like cuss words, or if you are someone who actually uses the term "cuss words", you may want to skip this post. Not that I'm about to start bandying the f-bomb around, but there will be repeated use of the d-word. And possibly also the s-word. So considered yourselves warned.
For the past few weeks, husband-dear have been church-hunting. We have, among other things, joined a "life group" (i.e., an adult bible study) at a church right around the corner from our house. We're not committing that church just yet, and we're also not entirely sure about the life group itself, especially after last night, but we figured we'd give it a try. Today, as I walked in with my heating pad and extension cord, one of the other life group attendees asked the obvious question ("why?") followed up by a less obvious question, "So your back is still not OK?", to which I responded with a heartfelt, "No. I mean, damn, it hurts."
The silence punctured by a few uneasy giggles that followed that statement made me realize I had once again committed a serious faux pas. You see, proper southern Christians do not swear. Or excuse me, cuss. Jesus doesn't like it.
So I quickly made up an excuse, and muttered something about having to give a come to Jesus talk to one of my students right before I left. Now this did actually happen. A fellow professor had complained to me about one my advisees running his mouth in class, and so when I saw said student, let's call him Jack, I called Jack into my office. Jack's excuse was that the professor had "crossed the line" a week prior, and Jack wasn't having any of it. What line had the professor crossed? Well, he had had the audacity to cuss Jack out. More specifically, he had told Jack to "stop messing around in class, dammit." So I asked the student what the professor had meant by "messing around", to which Jack responded he might have possibly been chatting and napping during class. Well, I argued, you probably needed a good wake up call then, didn't you?
"But, professor, he cussed. Like, OMG, you don't cuss." Jack sounded very sincere. Unfortunately, for Jack anyway, I know him a little too well.
"You cuss yourself, Jack, you know that."
"No I don't. Honestly, professor."
"Dammit Jack, have you read own tweets lately? They're not exactly G-rated either, are they?"I shook my head, "How can you play all high and mighty offended Christian when your own tweets use more cusswords than your average hip hop song? Seriously?"
At this point, Jack got the idea.
Unfortunately, my fellow life group members didn't.
"Oh no, " on of them exclaimed, "And here I was, feeling bad that today, when my second graders were really pushing my buttons, I no longer had the energy to tell them "shush", but instead told them to shut up. Wow."
A collective "oooh" indicated that this was, apparently, very bad, a thought further underlined by a second member's response, "Yeah, I always have my kindergartners tell on each other when that happens, 'Hey, Mrs. C., so and so just said the s-word', 'what did they say honey? It's OK you can tell me', 'well, they told me to shut up'. It's so cute"
So besides not discussing armpit hair, apparently telling someone to shut up is also unacceptable now. And the funny thing is, none of this is in the bible. Yes, there is the commandment that tells you to not use the Lord's name in vain, one which would lead my Jewish friend to edit that last sentence to spell "L-d". But unless one tells someone to shut up in God's (or G-d's) name, I'm not seeing it. And then of course there is Ephesians 4, where Paul tells his readers to let nothing but wholesome talk come from their mouths. When "damn" is used to reflect a "wow!" or "man!", is that unwholesome? When you tell a bunch of rowdy kids to shut up, is that not wholesome? Is learning to be quiet not wholesome? Apparently, I'm missing something here.
On the other hand, it does explain why my student was so upset. Not only was he cussed at, he was told in no uncertain terms to stop doing something. And that's not wholesome, apparently.
But seriously though, and I'm quoting The Princess Diaries here (an overall wholesome movie)
Shut. Up.
Showing posts with label The saga of students. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The saga of students. Show all posts
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Thursday, October 27, 2011
Super-intelligent
I wanted to write something uplifting, happy, and somewhat intelligent today. I really did. I considered writing about the weather, how it reminds me of the fall in the south of France. I considered writing about Halloween, and how I am actually considering giving into the whole decorating-insanity that our entire neighborhood has apparently fallen victim to. But instead, I started to grade student papers, and once again my spirits have plummeted into the depths of all creations.
The phrase that set me off this time was "Some of the major symbolic symbols".
Yes, "symbolic symbols". I'm not sure what else symbols can be, other than symbolic, but apparently this student really wanted to make sure I understood the symbols were, like, symbolic, yeah, like a whole lot, dude.
The papers I'm grading today were assigned for a course on persuasive communication. Personally, I like to think of this course as one of my less stringent ones. There are no scary statistical calculations, no extremely complicated theories, and no long-dead and possibly slightly insane philosophers to consider. Instead, we discuss all the facets of persuasion, use lots and lots of examples, analyze a few famous propaganda movies, and then focus on the effectiveness of persuasive communication. I would in fact go so far as to claim that it's one of the most interesting courses I teach.
One of the major assignments the students have to complete is watch several propaganda movies, and discuss them in terms of the techniques and definitions presented in class. Which do they use, what are they trying to achieve, etc. In my book, that's as easy an assignment as I can create.
Wrong.
Although some students jump ahead, writing lucid, unpretentious, well-researched papers, covering every angle I could possibly think of, others appear to drown in the material, flailing for the shore, holding on to poorly defined terms for dear life, and generally make a mess of it.
Take one of the movies, for instance. It's from the second world war, and features the dictator of all dictators. Students have to watch an excerpt, and are provided with a link to re-watch it at home if they have to. In spite of all of that, one of my students managed to claim that Hitler called unfaithful Germans "Un-American". Of course he would. Someone else happily took the theory that the director of the film (Leni Riefenstahl) had an affair with Hitler and ran with it, making, among other head-turners, the unforgettable statement that she thus "wasn't so much working for him as she was under him". And yet another student made the claim that this movie was propaganda for it "presented Hitler as a family-oriented man". Hmm. Never married, no children, yet family-oriented. Excellent. There was also a student who decided that using formal writing language is a waste of everyone's time, and who decided to call a failed attempt at persuasion a "snafu".
Then, of course, there is the random use of Capitalization, the complete misuse, of, commas, the all-too common "you're missing a", the fragmented sentences that I for the life of me can't imitate, the use of then instead of than, or maybe it was then after all, and those sentences that just seem to run on and on and on without an end in sight as though the student is afraid to just put that period down and be done with it.
You will, however, be happy to know that I have found one pinprick of light in the darkness: No plagiarism thus far. My reign as the Terrible Queen of Anti-Plagiarism is finally paying off. Can we have a hooray?
The phrase that set me off this time was "Some of the major symbolic symbols".
Yes, "symbolic symbols". I'm not sure what else symbols can be, other than symbolic, but apparently this student really wanted to make sure I understood the symbols were, like, symbolic, yeah, like a whole lot, dude.
The papers I'm grading today were assigned for a course on persuasive communication. Personally, I like to think of this course as one of my less stringent ones. There are no scary statistical calculations, no extremely complicated theories, and no long-dead and possibly slightly insane philosophers to consider. Instead, we discuss all the facets of persuasion, use lots and lots of examples, analyze a few famous propaganda movies, and then focus on the effectiveness of persuasive communication. I would in fact go so far as to claim that it's one of the most interesting courses I teach.
One of the major assignments the students have to complete is watch several propaganda movies, and discuss them in terms of the techniques and definitions presented in class. Which do they use, what are they trying to achieve, etc. In my book, that's as easy an assignment as I can create.
Wrong.
Although some students jump ahead, writing lucid, unpretentious, well-researched papers, covering every angle I could possibly think of, others appear to drown in the material, flailing for the shore, holding on to poorly defined terms for dear life, and generally make a mess of it.
Take one of the movies, for instance. It's from the second world war, and features the dictator of all dictators. Students have to watch an excerpt, and are provided with a link to re-watch it at home if they have to. In spite of all of that, one of my students managed to claim that Hitler called unfaithful Germans "Un-American". Of course he would. Someone else happily took the theory that the director of the film (Leni Riefenstahl) had an affair with Hitler and ran with it, making, among other head-turners, the unforgettable statement that she thus "wasn't so much working for him as she was under him". And yet another student made the claim that this movie was propaganda for it "presented Hitler as a family-oriented man". Hmm. Never married, no children, yet family-oriented. Excellent. There was also a student who decided that using formal writing language is a waste of everyone's time, and who decided to call a failed attempt at persuasion a "snafu".
Then, of course, there is the random use of Capitalization, the complete misuse, of, commas, the all-too common "you're missing a", the fragmented sentences that I for the life of me can't imitate, the use of then instead of than, or maybe it was then after all, and those sentences that just seem to run on and on and on without an end in sight as though the student is afraid to just put that period down and be done with it.
You will, however, be happy to know that I have found one pinprick of light in the darkness: No plagiarism thus far. My reign as the Terrible Queen of Anti-Plagiarism is finally paying off. Can we have a hooray?
Monday, August 15, 2011
Reading 101
If "Knock three times on the ceiling if you wa-ant me!"had been written for my life, it would have gone something like this, "Knock endlessly outside office hours and the door is clo-osed!"Honestly.
Before you all think I'm nothing but an ornery curmudgeon who absolutely detests students, allow me to explain.
In my current department, faculty is expected to hold ten office hours per week.
Yes, ten office hours. A fourth of our workweek. Ten. Hours.
While at most universities students are lucky if their professors can be found in their offices for maybe two hours on a Wednesday afternoon, we are expected to be available to students two hours each day. If you consider that most of us teach two classes per day (or three or four, if you're the lucky bug who got stuck with the overload), are expected to publish, and then have committee responsibilities as well, you can imagine that two hours is a lot. But we suck it up and do it. This year I actually decided to meet the increasing demand for face-time, and schedule in twelve office hours per week.
Twelve hours people. Add it all up, and it's a day and a half each week.
Granted, all my office hours are in the morning, which might be a tad earlier than students would like, but you know, I got stuff to do just as much as they do. Stuff that is technically essential to both their academic progress as well as my job security.
But I digress.
So in order to facilitate students' usage of my office hours, I have posted a sheet on my door with both my classes and my office hours on it. It's even color-coded, so students don't have to search for the word "office hours", but can instead look for the pretty purple boxes.
Now in previous years, I used to leave my door open outside of office hours too. I like a little bit of fresh air, to keep tabs on what's going on in the production lab down the hallway, and didn't mind students dropping in to ask a quick question if I had time. But last year, this "quick question" thing got a bit out of hand, and instead of showing up to my office hours, students would show up whenever they wanted to, which left me prepping classes, writing articles, and grading papers at home. Dr. D. did not like that at all. And Dr. D's husband liked it even less. So last semester, I started closing my door when I didn't have office hours, a practice I started up again today.
And let me tell you, it has been one tough learning curve for my darling snowflakes. They knock, and when I don't answer, they knock again. Then they'll knock even louder, and sometimes they'll even call out my name. On a few occasions they've even yelled, "I know you're in there!', or called my phone from right outside my office, demanding that I talk to them "just real quick, I promise!"
Usually I just ignore them, and they'll eventually go away. A few times, when the yelling got so loud that co-workers started to peek out of their offices trying to find out what was going on, I've opened my door and told them in very succinct terms when my next office hours were, and then closed the door on them again.
I realize my students think I'm not "nice", but I really don't understand why this has taken such a long time for them to understand. There's a sheet on my door, my office hours are on my syllabus, and you would think that my ignoring them would give them a very obvious clue. I've debated putting an even larger sign on my door that says, "If the door is closed it means office hours are over. Don't knock". Or perhaps the more brief but more abrasive, "Don't bother knocking if the door is closed" will work.
Then again, if those devastating test results were correct, the whole reading thing may be the problem. Perhaps the solution is just to take a sheet of paper, draw a big arrow on it, write "READ" next to the arrow, and hang it beside the schedule posted on my door. Who knows, it might work. After all, don't they say that hope springs eternal?
Before you all think I'm nothing but an ornery curmudgeon who absolutely detests students, allow me to explain.
In my current department, faculty is expected to hold ten office hours per week.
Yes, ten office hours. A fourth of our workweek. Ten. Hours.
While at most universities students are lucky if their professors can be found in their offices for maybe two hours on a Wednesday afternoon, we are expected to be available to students two hours each day. If you consider that most of us teach two classes per day (or three or four, if you're the lucky bug who got stuck with the overload), are expected to publish, and then have committee responsibilities as well, you can imagine that two hours is a lot. But we suck it up and do it. This year I actually decided to meet the increasing demand for face-time, and schedule in twelve office hours per week.
Twelve hours people. Add it all up, and it's a day and a half each week.
Granted, all my office hours are in the morning, which might be a tad earlier than students would like, but you know, I got stuff to do just as much as they do. Stuff that is technically essential to both their academic progress as well as my job security.
But I digress.
So in order to facilitate students' usage of my office hours, I have posted a sheet on my door with both my classes and my office hours on it. It's even color-coded, so students don't have to search for the word "office hours", but can instead look for the pretty purple boxes.
Now in previous years, I used to leave my door open outside of office hours too. I like a little bit of fresh air, to keep tabs on what's going on in the production lab down the hallway, and didn't mind students dropping in to ask a quick question if I had time. But last year, this "quick question" thing got a bit out of hand, and instead of showing up to my office hours, students would show up whenever they wanted to, which left me prepping classes, writing articles, and grading papers at home. Dr. D. did not like that at all. And Dr. D's husband liked it even less. So last semester, I started closing my door when I didn't have office hours, a practice I started up again today.
And let me tell you, it has been one tough learning curve for my darling snowflakes. They knock, and when I don't answer, they knock again. Then they'll knock even louder, and sometimes they'll even call out my name. On a few occasions they've even yelled, "I know you're in there!', or called my phone from right outside my office, demanding that I talk to them "just real quick, I promise!"
Usually I just ignore them, and they'll eventually go away. A few times, when the yelling got so loud that co-workers started to peek out of their offices trying to find out what was going on, I've opened my door and told them in very succinct terms when my next office hours were, and then closed the door on them again.
I realize my students think I'm not "nice", but I really don't understand why this has taken such a long time for them to understand. There's a sheet on my door, my office hours are on my syllabus, and you would think that my ignoring them would give them a very obvious clue. I've debated putting an even larger sign on my door that says, "If the door is closed it means office hours are over. Don't knock". Or perhaps the more brief but more abrasive, "Don't bother knocking if the door is closed" will work.
Then again, if those devastating test results were correct, the whole reading thing may be the problem. Perhaps the solution is just to take a sheet of paper, draw a big arrow on it, write "READ" next to the arrow, and hang it beside the schedule posted on my door. Who knows, it might work. After all, don't they say that hope springs eternal?
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
Listen carefully...
...for I shall say this only once
Michelle ~ Allo, Allo
After four years at my current school, and ten years of teaching in higher education, I have can now confidently claim to know the key to academic success:
Listen.
Lame? Absolutely not. Obvious? Don't think so.
Yes, you need intelligence. And the ability to plan and prioritize. Not to mention a healthy dosage of work ethic. But above all, you need to listen, and listen well. Don't just look at me as though you're listening, but really open your ears and pay attention.
Seriously, if students were to do this, their life (and mine) would be so much easier. For one thing, there would be no need for me to repeat where the registrar's office is three times to the same student. Freshmen advisement sessions would last thirty minutes at best, and not need to take hours and hours because students had not listened properly and thus did not know what to do. Forms could be explained once, and that would be it. In short, advisement would take half the time it does now.
And if advisement were to be this affected by carefully listening students, imagine what it would do to my classes! We would actually have time to debate some of the concepts introduced in the classroom, as there would be no need to repeat due dates, minimum page requirements, book titles, and group assignments.
In case you think I'm joking: the staff member in the office next to mine has been able to tell students what they wanted to know about advisement and my class for about a year now because she's heard me repeat myself over and over and over again. Even husband-dear knows my class deadlines better than some of my students. And after one long phone-advisement session, the kids, much to my merriment, were able to repeat my "please make sure you take such and such form to this and that office" mantra without any mistakes.
Some days I think I should just create a set of note cards with some standard answers that I can just hold up when students come in. Or simply hand them the handbook and make them read it front to back until they found the answer themselves.
Instead, however, I've (well, a co-worker found it here) found something far better. I'm going to give my students a "how well do you pay attention" quiz at the beginning of the semester. It may not focus on listening, but paying attention is pretty close. For your amusement, I have pasted the quiz below. And those of you who read this entire blog and scoffed? Take it, please. And let me know how well you did.
Three minute timed test.
1. Read everything before doing anything.
2. Put your name in the upper left-hand corner of this paper
3. Circle the word "name" in sentence two
4. Draw five small squares in the upper left hand corner of this paper
5. Put an X in each square
6. Sign your name under the title of this paper.
7. After the title write "Yes, yes, yes."
8. Put a circle around sentence seven.
9. Put an X in the lower left-hand corner of this paper
10. Draw a triangle around the X you just put down.
11. On the back of this paper, multiply 70 by 43.
12. Call out your first name when you get this point in the test.
13. If you think you have followed directions up to this point, call out "I have"
14. In your normal speaking voice, count from ten to one backward
15. Punch three small holes in the top of this paper with your pencil
16. If you are the first person to get this far, call out loudly "I am the first person to get to this point, and I am the leader in following directions!"
17. Underline all even numbers on the side of this page
18. Put a square around every number written on this test.
19. Say out loud, "I am nearly finished, I have followed directions!"
20. Now that you have finished reading the directions, do only number 2.
Michelle ~ Allo, Allo
After four years at my current school, and ten years of teaching in higher education, I have can now confidently claim to know the key to academic success:
Listen.
Lame? Absolutely not. Obvious? Don't think so.
Yes, you need intelligence. And the ability to plan and prioritize. Not to mention a healthy dosage of work ethic. But above all, you need to listen, and listen well. Don't just look at me as though you're listening, but really open your ears and pay attention.
Seriously, if students were to do this, their life (and mine) would be so much easier. For one thing, there would be no need for me to repeat where the registrar's office is three times to the same student. Freshmen advisement sessions would last thirty minutes at best, and not need to take hours and hours because students had not listened properly and thus did not know what to do. Forms could be explained once, and that would be it. In short, advisement would take half the time it does now.
And if advisement were to be this affected by carefully listening students, imagine what it would do to my classes! We would actually have time to debate some of the concepts introduced in the classroom, as there would be no need to repeat due dates, minimum page requirements, book titles, and group assignments.
In case you think I'm joking: the staff member in the office next to mine has been able to tell students what they wanted to know about advisement and my class for about a year now because she's heard me repeat myself over and over and over again. Even husband-dear knows my class deadlines better than some of my students. And after one long phone-advisement session, the kids, much to my merriment, were able to repeat my "please make sure you take such and such form to this and that office" mantra without any mistakes.
Some days I think I should just create a set of note cards with some standard answers that I can just hold up when students come in. Or simply hand them the handbook and make them read it front to back until they found the answer themselves.
Instead, however, I've (well, a co-worker found it here) found something far better. I'm going to give my students a "how well do you pay attention" quiz at the beginning of the semester. It may not focus on listening, but paying attention is pretty close. For your amusement, I have pasted the quiz below. And those of you who read this entire blog and scoffed? Take it, please. And let me know how well you did.
Three minute timed test.
1. Read everything before doing anything.
2. Put your name in the upper left-hand corner of this paper
3. Circle the word "name" in sentence two
4. Draw five small squares in the upper left hand corner of this paper
5. Put an X in each square
6. Sign your name under the title of this paper.
7. After the title write "Yes, yes, yes."
8. Put a circle around sentence seven.
9. Put an X in the lower left-hand corner of this paper
10. Draw a triangle around the X you just put down.
11. On the back of this paper, multiply 70 by 43.
12. Call out your first name when you get this point in the test.
13. If you think you have followed directions up to this point, call out "I have"
14. In your normal speaking voice, count from ten to one backward
15. Punch three small holes in the top of this paper with your pencil
16. If you are the first person to get this far, call out loudly "I am the first person to get to this point, and I am the leader in following directions!"
17. Underline all even numbers on the side of this page
18. Put a square around every number written on this test.
19. Say out loud, "I am nearly finished, I have followed directions!"
20. Now that you have finished reading the directions, do only number 2.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)